Connexion
  • Mon espace
RDN Association loi 1904, fondée en 1939 RDN Le débat stratégique depuis 1939
  • Panier - 0 article
  • La Revue
  • e-RDN
    • Tribune
    • e-Recensions
    • Cahiers de la RDN
    • Débats stratégiques
    • Florilège historique
    • Repères
    • Brèves
  • Boutique
    • Abonnements
    • Crédits articles
    • Points de vente
    • Conditions générales de vente
  • Bibliothèque
    • Recherche
    • Auteurs
    • Anciens numéros
  • La RDN
    • Présentation
    • Comité d'études
    • L'équipe
    • Contact
    • Lettre d'infos
    • Agenda
  • Liens utiles
  • Mon espace
  • Connexion
  • Connexion

    Email :

    Mot de passe :

  • La Revue
  • e-RDN
    • Tribune
    • e-Recensions
    • Cahiers de la RDN
    • Débats stratégiques
    • Florilège historique
    • Repères
    • Brèves
  • Boutique
    • Abonnements
    • Crédits articles
    • Points de vente
    • Conditions générales de vente
  • Bibliothèque
    • Recherche
    • Auteurs
    • Anciens numéros
  • La RDN
    • Présentation
    • Comité d'études
    • L'équipe
    • Contact
    • Lettre d'infos
    • Agenda
  • Liens utiles
  • Accueil
  • e-RDN
  • Revue n° 691 November 2006
  • Hiroshima and Yasukuni: Japan, a Prisoner of its History

Hiroshima and Yasukuni: Japan, a Prisoner of its History

Bernard Dupuy d'Angeac, "Hiroshima and Yasukuni: Japan, a Prisoner of its History " Revue n° 691 November 2006

The Japanese are still torn between pacifism and national security requirements. Pacifism is gradually being replaced by patriotism built on the falsification of school history books, which appals Japan’s neighbours, while East Asian geopolitics are being buffeted by North Korean weapon tests and the revision of the Japanese Constitution. Can Japan break free from its history? It must first acknowledge the errors of the past, and could subsequently adopt a form of Gaullism. A non-nuclear Japan could then play a role in Asia appropriate to the world’s second economic power.

More than 60 years ago, Japan experienced the horrors of nuclear bombardment, and every year ceremonies are held to recall those terrible events that the whole world would wish never to recur. Shortly after the two bombs were dropped, Japan concluded a long war that it had conducted ‘in self-defence and to preserve its Empire’. As well as the soldiers killed in action, 14 of the men responsible for the war are honoured in the Yasukuni shrine. Hiroshima, Nagasaki and Yasukuni are today far more than memorial sites, painful for all Japanese: they mark a borderline in their twentieth-century history, and are still determinant in their major political decisions.

In the nineteenth century no other Asian country had managed to abandon a feudal political system so rapidly, and in a few decades to catch up on the West and become a modern state. Japan was then, like Korea and China, a sort of hermit kingdom, sealed within its frontiers, until the Western powers forced them to open their ports to foreign vessels. This coercive opening-up stirred Japanese patriotism, a mixture of the Samurai code and Emperor-worship, and this unbending patriotism allowed Japan to maintain its independence, by accelerating the modernisation process. In 1945 Japanese patriotism, associated with militarism, was condemned by the American occupying power, and the vanquished, deprived of their national myths, took refuge in the past. Whereas in the nineteenth century Japan succeeded in liberating itself effortlessly from several centuries of history in order to move more rapidly into the modern era, nowadays it is paralysed by passionate attachment to its past, as though it has become a prisoner of its own history.

The Japanese are not alone in being prisoners of their history, blaming endless squabbles with their neighbours on Fate. Greeks and Turks, Israelis and Palestinians, Indians and Pakistanis, etc. Some hereditary enemies, like the Poles and the Russians, or the Germans and the French, have managed to break out of the vicious cycle of massacre. After three wars, two of them World Wars, Germans and French at last understood that to build Europe they had to become reconciled and form an entity of two countries united once and for all. An important step in the reconciliation process came with the tranquilising of a turbulent past, thanks to the work of historians who showed that errors were made on both banks of the Rhine.

Il reste 88 % de l'article à lire

L'article a bien été ajouté au panier.

Mon panierContinuer mes achats

Partagez...

  • Accéder au sommaire du numéro

Avril 2026
n° 889

Des armées innovantes

Je participe au débat stratégique


À vos claviers,
réagissez au dossier du mois

 

Actualités

18-04-2026

Liban : décès d’un militaire engagé sur l’opération DAMAN

09-04-2026

Eurosatory 2026 : vers une édition record dans un contexte de réarmement massif

08-04-2026

Adaptation capacitaire : nouvelle capacité de lutte anti-drone par le drone Reaper de l’AAE

08-04-2026

La DGA commande la 5e FDI à Naval Group

01-04-2026

Un SNA met en œuvre un drone depuis son dry deck shelter

18-03-2026

Vient de paraître : Les armées françaises, Jérôme Pellistrandi dans la collection « Que Sais-je »

Adhérez au CEDN

et bénéficiez d'un statut privilégié et d'avantages exclusifs (invitations...)

Anciens numéros

Accéder aux sommaires des revues de 1939 à aujourd’hui

Agenda

Colloques, manifestations, expositions...

Liens utiles

Institutions, ministères, médias...

Lettre d'infos

Boutique

  • Abonnements
  • Crédits articles
  • Points de vente
  • CGV
  • Politique de confidentialité / Mentions légales

e-RDN

  • Tribune
  • e-Recensions
  • Cahiers de la RDN
  • Florilège historique
  • Repères

Informations

La Revue Défense Nationale est éditée par le Comité d’études de défense nationale (association loi de 1901)

Directeur de la publication : Luc de Rancourt

Adresse géographique : École militaire,
1 place Joffre, Paris VII

Nous contacter

Tél. : 01 44 42 31 90

Email : contact@defnat.com

Adresse : BP 8607, 75325 Paris cedex 07

Publicité : 01 44 42 31 91

Copyright © Bialec Tous droits réservés.